Skip to content

Derivative Test Comparison

Run the Derivative Test Comparison MicroSim Fullscreen

Edit the Derivative Test Comparison MicroSim with the p5.js editor

Embed This MicroSim

You can include this MicroSim on your website using the following iframe:

1
<iframe src="https://dmccreary.github.io/calculus/sims/derivative-test-comparison/main.html" height="562px" width="100%" scrolling="no"></iframe>

Description

This MicroSim provides a side-by-side comparison of the First Derivative Test and Second Derivative Test for classifying critical points of functions. The visualization helps students understand:

  1. When each test is appropriate: The Second Derivative Test is faster (1 evaluation vs 3) but fails when f''(c) = 0
  2. How each test works: Sign charts for the First Derivative Test, concavity analysis for the Second Derivative Test
  3. Why the First Derivative Test is more reliable: It always gives a conclusive answer, while the Second Derivative Test can be inconclusive

Features

  • Three-panel layout: Left panel shows First Derivative Test with sign chart, center shows function graph with marked critical points, right panel shows Second Derivative Test with concavity indicator
  • Five test functions: Including examples where the Second Derivative Test fails (x^5 at x=0) and where it works well
  • Color-coded results: Red for local maximum, blue for local minimum, yellow for inconclusive
  • Step-by-step breakdown: Each panel shows the computational steps required
  • Summary comparison: Bottom bar shows both test results and recommends which test to use

Controls

Control Description
Function buttons Select from 5 different test functions
Critical Point slider Navigate between critical points of the selected function
Show Both toggle Show or hide both test panels

Lesson Plan

Learning Objective

Students will be able to compare the First and Second Derivative Tests and choose the appropriate method for classifying critical points.

Bloom's Taxonomy Level

Analyze (L4) - Compare, contrast, differentiate

Prerequisites

  • Understanding of critical points (where f'(x) = 0)
  • Ability to compute first and second derivatives
  • Knowledge of concavity and its relationship to the second derivative

Guided Exploration (15 minutes)

  1. Start with f(x) = x^3 - 3x: This function has two critical points where both tests work well
  2. At x = -1, observe both tests identify a local maximum
  3. At x = 1, observe both tests identify a local minimum

  4. Note the Second Derivative Test requires fewer evaluations

  5. Try f(x) = x^5: This is the crucial example

  6. At x = 0, the Second Derivative Test is INCONCLUSIVE (f''(0) = 0)
  7. The First Derivative Test correctly identifies this as neither max nor min

  8. Discuss: Why does the Second Derivative Test fail here?

  9. Examine f(x) = x^4: Another important case

  10. At x = 0, the Second Derivative Test ALSO fails (f''(0) = 0)
  11. But this IS a local minimum (the First Derivative Test shows - to + sign change)

  12. Key insight: f''(c) = 0 does NOT mean "neither max nor min"

  13. Compare f(x) = x^4 - 2x^2: Multiple critical points

  14. Navigate through all three critical points
  15. Notice the Second Derivative Test works at x = -1 and x = 1
  16. Compare computation time for each method

Discussion Questions

  1. If the Second Derivative Test is faster, why don't we always use it?
  2. What types of functions tend to cause the Second Derivative Test to fail?
  3. Can you think of a real-world scenario where computational efficiency matters (favoring the Second Derivative Test)?

Assessment

Ask students to complete this table for a new function without using the MicroSim:

Function Critical Point First Test Result Second Test Result
f(x) = x^3 + 3x^2 x = ? ? ?
f(x) = x^6 x = ? ? ?

References