Skip to content

Shifting the Burden: IT Help Desk Quick Fixes vs. Training Investment

This is an example of the "Shifting the Burden" systems archetype, where an organization becomes dependent on quick fixes that actually prevent long-term solutions.

The Problem Symptom

A company's IT help desk is overwhelmed with tickets from employees who can't perform basic computer tasks. Productivity is suffering as employees wait for help with routine issues like password resets, software installation, printer setup, and basic troubleshooting.

The Quick Fix (Symptom Relief)

Management decides to hire more IT help desk staff and implement a 24/7 support system. They also create detailed step-by-step guides that IT staff can quickly walk employees through over the phone or via remote desktop.

Initial Success

The quick fix provides immediate relief:

  • Ticket response time improves dramatically from hours to minutes
  • Employee frustration decreases as they get immediate help
  • Productivity appears to recover as employees get back to work quickly
  • Management sees measurable improvement in help desk metrics
  • IT staff feel valuable and needed as problem solvers
  • Short-term costs seem reasonable compared to productivity losses

The Fundamental Solution (Avoided)

The real solution would be to invest in comprehensive employee tech training: - Regular hands-on workshops for basic computer skills - Self-service training modules employees can access - "Train the trainer" programs to build internal expertise - Better onboarding processes that include tech literacy - User-friendly systems that require less support

Unintended Consequences of the Quick Fix

Within 6-12 months, several problems emerge:

  • Employee tech skills actually decline as they become dependent on IT support
  • Help desk ticket volume continues growing despite more staff
  • More complex issues emerge as employees never learn fundamentals
  • IT costs spiral upward with increasing staffing needs
  • Employee learned helplessness develops - they stop trying to solve simple problems
  • Critical IT projects get delayed as staff focus on routine support

Weakening of Fundamental Capability

The quick fix systematically undermines the organization's ability to implement the real solution:

  • Training budgets get cut because "we already solved the IT problem"
  • Employees resist training because "IT will just fix it for me"
  • Managers see training as unnecessary since help desk metrics look good
  • IT staff become firefighters with no time to develop training programs
  • Knowledge transfer stops as employees expect to be walked through everything
  • Self-reliance culture erodes across the organization

The Addiction Cycle

The organization becomes addicted to IT support: - Every new software requires extensive help desk support - Employee confidence decreases in their ability to learn new systems
- Help desk becomes a crutch that employees can't function without - More sophisticated quick fixes are needed (premium support contracts, AI chatbots) - Fundamental capability continues declining as dependency deepens - Breaking the cycle becomes increasingly difficult as culture shifts

The System Structure

Problem Symptom (IT tickets) → Quick Fix (more help desk staff) → Temporary Relief → Reduced Capability (employee skills decline) → Worse Problem (more tickets, complex issues) → More Quick Fixes

Meanwhile, the Fundamental Solution (training) is avoided because: - The quick fix provides immediate relief - Training seems unnecessary when help desk works well - Training requires long-term investment and commitment - Results from training take months to appear

Breaking the Pattern

To escape this trap, the organization needs to:

  1. Acknowledge the addiction - recognize that high help desk usage indicates a systemic problem
  2. Invest in the fundamental solution - comprehensive, ongoing tech training programs
  3. Gradually reduce dependency - implement "teach don't fix" policies where appropriate
  4. Measure different metrics - track employee self-sufficiency rather than just response times
  5. Change the culture - celebrate employee problem-solving rather than quick IT fixes
  6. Provide transition support - maintain help desk while building internal capabilities

The Leverage Point

The highest leverage intervention is changing the help desk's mission from "fixing problems quickly" to "building employee capability." This means: - IT staff are trained to teach, not just solve - Tickets include learning components when possible
- Self-service options are prioritized over direct support - Success is measured by reduced dependency, not faster response

This example demonstrates how well-intentioned quick fixes can create organizational dependencies that make fundamental problems worse over time, requiring systems thinking to identify and break these destructive patterns.

Questions for Reflection

  1. How does the quick fix actually prevent the fundamental solution?
  2. What role does measurement play in reinforcing the wrong approach?
  3. Why is it so difficult for organizations to recognize this pattern?
  4. What other examples of "shifting the burden" can you identify in your workplace?
  5. How might an organization transition from quick fixes to fundamental solutions without disrupting operations?