Skip to content

Policy Claim Evaluator

Run the Policy Claim Evaluator MicroSim Fullscreen
Edit in the p5.js Editor

About This MicroSim

This MicroSim presents students with common economic policy claims from politicians, commentators, and activists, and challenges them to evaluate each claim's accuracy. For each claim, students identify logical red flags (such as absolute language, oversimplification, or ignoring key economic concepts), then render a verdict of Accurate, Misleading, or Needs Context. After submitting, the simulator reveals the correct answer with a detailed economic analysis and a key insight. Claims cover topics ranging from government spending and minimum wage to trade policy and national debt, at Basic, Intermediate, and Advanced difficulty levels.

How to Use

  1. Select Difficulty -- Use the difficulty dropdown to filter claims by Basic, Intermediate, Advanced, or All levels.
  2. Read the Claim -- Carefully read the policy statement displayed in the claim card, noting the source and source type.
  3. Identify Red Flags -- Check the boxes for any logical or economic red flags you detect in the claim.
  4. Choose Your Verdict -- Select "Accurate," "Misleading," or "Needs Context" from the verdict dropdown.
  5. Submit Your Evaluation -- Click "Submit Evaluation" to check your answer. The analysis panel reveals the correct verdict, a better analysis, and a key economic insight.
  6. Move to Next Claim -- Click "Next Claim" to advance to the next policy statement. Your score is tracked at the top right.

Iframe Embed Code

You can add this MicroSim to any web page by adding this to your HTML:

<iframe src="https://dmccreary.github.io/economics-course/sims/policy-evaluator/main.html"
        height="602px"
        width="100%"
        scrolling="no"></iframe>

Lesson Plan

Grade Level

9-12 (High School Economics)

Duration

10-15 minutes

Prerequisites

  • Understanding of basic economic concepts (GDP, inflation, unemployment, fiscal policy)
  • Familiarity with critical thinking and evaluating sources
  • Knowledge of common economic policy debates

Activities

  1. Exploration (5 min): Have students work through 2-3 Basic-level claims individually, reading each claim carefully and trying to identify red flags before looking at the analysis. Discuss as a class what red flags were easiest and hardest to spot.
  2. Guided Practice (5 min): Work through an Intermediate or Advanced claim together as a class. Before submitting, have students debate their verdicts and reasoning. Compare their analysis to the simulator's explanation.
  3. Assessment (5 min): Students complete the remaining claims independently, then write a short reflection on which type of misleading claim is most common in real-world economic debates and how to recognize it.

Assessment

  • Can the student identify logical red flags in economic policy claims (absolute language, oversimplification, ignoring key variables)?
  • Can the student distinguish between claims that are misleading vs. those that need additional context?
  • Does the student demonstrate improved critical thinking about economic claims from media and political sources?

References

  1. Critical thinking - Wikipedia
  2. Media literacy - Wikipedia
  3. Economic policy - Investopedia